A little while ago 45n5 was asking for a new layout for his site. He wasn’t looking for anything coded, he wanted the PSD file for it so (I would assume) he could code it. I thought this was perfect since I’m not strong in the world of coding and I love to design - so I took a shot at it.
His contest was up at SitePoint and I noticed (why I didn’t before.. I don’t know) that there were quite a few contest running for an un-coded template for their sites. I thought this was manna from heaven - and why not give this a whirl and make a few extra dollars doing something I LOVE TO DO! It just seemed to work - and I went about it, and submitted to 3 other contests. It was with these other contests that I started to see a trend.
… a not-so-nifty trend.
… if you are a designer.
1. You enter your template for their review based on their requests in the contest.
2. You sit and wait to see if the contest holder has any suggestions.
3. You get a response on some “tweaking” needed for the template
4. You re-tweak the site and think this should now be it.
5. You get a response from the contest holder that he/she is now looking for different colors/shading.
6. You start to feel like your being played a fool.
7. Other entrants base their “new” designs on yours, because yours is the only one that “worked”.
8. Focus shifts from your design to theirs.
9. They win the contest.
Yes, about 9 nifty steps… although I think I left out the majority of “re-do’s” on those templates - after 4 I tend to lose interest. Either you like the design - or you don’t. If it’s a case of aesthetic design tweaks - that can easily be done AFTER the contest has been won by me… or whomever. Don’t go asking designers to make so many changes and then not choose them. What a WASTE OF TIME!
But the bad thing about some of the contests here, was that the designers kept coming back over and over and over again with new tweaks and changes and more changes - some were up around 9 re-designs and still coming back to “win” their $200. I think at some point they should have just said - enough is enough. But they don’t. I’m not sure if they realize as a designer how screwed they are. Wasting so much time - never guaranteed if they’ll win it or not. Wasted time - on some who are actually quite talented.
I see it all the time in my real world job - and there comes a point where it’s just too much. You have to take a stand and say enough is enough and set up limits. Because I think in the end you just have a screwed over feeling.
I guess what I’m saying in this little rant - is that if you put on a contest or participate in these contests, there has to be a certain amount of give and take. If you hold the contest and love a design - but maybe need different colours or a tweak in the layout - do it after that person has won the contest. I think the response would be super positive and easily done.
As a designer - figure out when to say enough is enough and layout the ground rules - like changing things on the template once. Won’t sit around and “tweak” it 19 times only to lose the contest to some goob who shows up in the last hour with a design based off yours with all the tweaking and then some… so frustrating.
So I guess for me I’m laying low in that area - as fun as it was, it just became so freakin’ frustrating.
Popularity: 6% [?]












Recent Comments